Reviews from

Happy Mel May Day

Celebrating two special days

68 total reviews 
Comment from Boogienights
Excellent
Not yet exceptional. When the exceptional rating is reached this is highlighted

This is so sweet, she's veryucky to have you in her life. It makes mayday even more special to have a birthday on the same day...cause for Celebration. Thank you for sharing your lovely poem with us, best of luck in the contest. :)

 Comment Written 01-May-2022


reply by the author on 01-May-2022
    Since mother in-laws always get a bad rap, I'm proud that my son picked such a sweet girl, who I love dearly! I couldn't pass up an opportunity to write a poem for May Day, which was also Mel's birthday and have a little fun with it. Thanks Sweetie for your kind review and very lovely comments. Debi
reply by Boogienights on 01-May-2022
Comment from jessizero
Excellent
Not yet exceptional. When the exceptional rating is reached this is highlighted

I like your poem for your daughter (in law). I am sure she must have enjoyed it, too. I hope you gave her a nice female day for her birthday. :) Best wishes.

 Comment Written 01-May-2022


reply by the author on 01-May-2022
    Since mother in-laws always get a bad rap, I'm proud that my son picked such a sweet girl, who I love dearly! I couldn't pass up an opportunity to write a poem for May Day, which was also Mel's birthday and have a little fun with it. Thanks Jessi for your kind review and very lovely comments. Debi
Comment from Paul McFarland
Excellent
Not yet exceptional. When the exceptional rating is reached this is highlighted

I see you are in Minnesota. Spring has a tough time breaking through out there. Here in Maine, it struggles sometime, but it's not as bad as you have it.

 Comment Written 01-May-2022


reply by the author on 01-May-2022
    Paul, I absolutely love Maine! My husband and I went east in the Autumn one year, and after stopping on at Mackinaw Island and Niagara Falls, we went to Maine and traveled the East coast. You are much like MN where the Fall colors are beautiful!. Regarding my poem, since mother in-laws always get a bad rap, I'm proud that my son picked such a sweet girl, who I love dearly! I couldn't pass up an opportunity to write a poem for May Day, which was also Mel's birthday and have a little fun with it. Thanks Paul for reading and reviewing it. Debi
Comment from Frank Malley
Good
Not yet exceptional. When the exceptional rating is reached this is highlighted

"Happy Mel May Day" celebrates in simple words an important person's birthday. The poem's love and good will are unmistakable, and while it's not a stellar poem, it's good.

 Comment Written 01-May-2022


reply by the author on 01-May-2022
    Thanks Frank, you know how much I respect you and your feedback, so I love hearing your opinion. LOL, you should have seen it right after I lost it while editing and realized that I also forgot to save the original. Then I was panicking thinking that theres people out there who maybe reviewing this mess. I was frantic! I should have never posted anything, because I had had a blood transfusion and and other stuff done, so I agree, I can do better.
    I'm not doing a pity party, but instead admitting that when they say go home and sleep. I should do that. I certainly understand what a mess I made by jumping the gun on posting something thats not ready yet.
reply by Frank Malley on 01-May-2022
    It is a fine birthday greeting! To be or not to be poetry, that is the quest...
reply by the author on 01-May-2022
    You are so funny Frank!
    I just couldn't pass up an opportunity to honor
    Mel and May together : )
Comment from Bill Schott
Excellent
Not yet exceptional. When the exceptional rating is reached this is highlighted

This poem, Happy Mel May Day, brings the readers to the understanding that Mel was born on the first day of May. Now I might be wrong, but I'm not. Happy MelMay Day!

 Comment Written 01-May-2022


reply by the author on 01-May-2022
    Lol, I will pass on the message to the birthday girl!
    Thank you my awesome friend! : )
Comment from RGstar
Excellent
Not yet exceptional. When the exceptional rating is reached this is highlighted

What a lovely thing. I really like the way you have written this (as if a sketch) full of imagination. Bravo.
And what better symbol could one have? Mel's eyes light the gloom of any winter, she is radiant and beautiful. Welcome the turning of seasons. May you both be well and enjoy life to the fullest, only one, as we know it.
My best wishes.
Hay May Day Mel.
RGstar

 Comment Written 01-May-2022


reply by the author on 01-May-2022
    Lol, your reviews are so much fun to read RG, and I thank you so very much for your sweet comments and review.

    I just got done reading your interview with Terry, and I must say that I was so completely impressed
    .
    Because my style has always been ( for the most part) a bit of comical with an end twist. So I agreed 100% that what is between the lines are so important, rather than just rhyming.
    I would really be honored if you would read some of them as I always worry about overdoing the silly. Thanks so much RG!
Comment from Terry Palardy
Excellent
Not yet exceptional. When the exceptional rating is reached this is highlighted

What a gentle, kind poem you've written for your daughter in law ... an easy rhyme, and a smooth meter, though I confess it was a bit of a tongue twister to read aloud! Thanks for sharing this, and happy birthdqay to MEL!

 Comment Written 30-Apr-2022


reply by the author on 01-May-2022
    Thanks so much Terry as you are so very kind.. I will tell Mel about you and awesome friends, & all the great messages for her. I thank you for your lovely review and sweet comments.
Comment from Dolly'sPoems
Excellent
Not yet exceptional. When the exceptional rating is reached this is highlighted

A fine poem for this girl's birthday and how sweet to be born on the first say of May as she brings the sunshine with her, a fine tributary poem, much enjoyed Debi, love Dolly x

 Comment Written 30-Apr-2022


reply by the author on 30-Apr-2022
    Thanks Dolly, I am so appreciative for your lovely review and kind comments. Hopefully I can print the poem to give it to her tomorrow
    Thanks again Dolly, you are a gem!
Comment from nomi338
Excellent
Not yet exceptional. When the exceptional rating is reached this is highlighted

She should christen Mayday as 'Myday' and celebrate it like it is a Friday. Drink and dance without care or concern. Hey, one day out of 365, you must be allowed a bit of freedom right? With your help and encouragement, you can make it happen.

 Comment Written 30-Apr-2022


reply by the author on 30-Apr-2022
    Haha! Believe me, we used to. In my book that I wrote poems for everyone in my family; one stanza of Mel's Poem reads like this,
    " you and I became very good friends, we talked and we laughed with good cheer, Had us some fun, sang us some songs, as we sat at the bar with a beer!" ......... Thanks Nomi for always making me smile!
reply by nomi338 on 01-May-2022
    I like it!
Comment from Katherine M. (k-11)
Excellent
Not yet exceptional. When the exceptional rating is reached this is highlighted

Happy Birthday to Mel! What an auspicious day for her birthday. On Mayday we give out lilies of the valley to our loved ladies, for good luck. You have painted in your twelve lines a very clear picture of Mel. Thanks.

 Comment Written 30-Apr-2022


reply by the author on 30-Apr-2022
    Oh Katherine, that is so awesome what you said about the Lilies of theValley flowers. Those are Mel's favorite! She had them in her wedding to my son, has them in her yard and planted them on both sides of the creek that separates our two yards, brought together by a lovely bridge that my son built, so the boys could come to grandmas house safely.
    You are so very kind and I will pass on your birthday wishes to Mel and tell her the story of the flowers.
reply by Katherine M. (k-11) on 30-Apr-2022
    gift of lily of the valley is here in France
reply by the author on 30-Apr-2022
    Lol, I think I will tell my husband that I must go to France for a present for Mel!