The Comma - part one.
pause...30 total reviews
Comment from Rikki66
They are also my bane. This is a well-put-together piece, I'll never remember all those rules, especially, the adverbial. That is the reason I pay a premium for Grammarly.
RikkiLXVI
t
  |
They are also my bane. This is a well-put-together piece, I'll never remember all those rules, especially, the adverbial. That is the reason I pay a premium for Grammarly.
RikkiLXVI
t
Comment Written 25-Feb-2021
Comment from robyn corum
Gareth,
Nice work! And brave, as well. Imagine a student - daughter of a well-known and highly revered writer getting low marks in writing and writing skills when she is homeschooled by said father. YIKES. I think it behooves you mightily to get this class RIGHT. hahaha
One note:
'I packed swimming trunks, towel, sunscreen and spare clothes for the trip.'
--> the Oxford comma says to also use a comma after 'sunscreen'
--> surely you've heard about THAT lawsuit.
Thanks! On to part II
reply by the author on 25-Feb-2021
|
Gareth,
Nice work! And brave, as well. Imagine a student - daughter of a well-known and highly revered writer getting low marks in writing and writing skills when she is homeschooled by said father. YIKES. I think it behooves you mightily to get this class RIGHT. hahaha
One note:
'I packed swimming trunks, towel, sunscreen and spare clothes for the trip.'
--> the Oxford comma says to also use a comma after 'sunscreen'
--> surely you've heard about THAT lawsuit.
Thanks! On to part II
Comment Written 25-Feb-2021
reply by the author on 25-Feb-2021
-
Yeah, I elected to leave out the Oxford comma, for now, as it isn't actually a compulsory article of punctuation. I would use it but it does get a bit confusing for some folk. The textbooks don't mention it. Some style guides say you must use it, others say not to. I decided to keep it simple here.
-
That's weird because in the second part you have added it.
-
Yep, but again it's not essential. if it was not there, the meaning wouldn't change.
Comment from Justin Chopin
Great, information Giraffmang. I'm horrible, with commas so I'm glad that you were able to give some guide lines about how to properly use these pesky little pieces of grammar. Well done.
|
Great, information Giraffmang. I'm horrible, with commas so I'm glad that you were able to give some guide lines about how to properly use these pesky little pieces of grammar. Well done.
Comment Written 25-Feb-2021
Comment from Father Flaps
Hi Gareth,
Gotcha!
"This is sometimes called the 'parenthesis' and in this case is a relative clause as it tells us more about the boy."
(This is sometimes called the 'parenthesis' and, in this case, is a relative clause as it tells us more about the boy.)
Okay, so I've added two commas, right or wrong. But should there be another before "as it tells us more about the boy".
At my age, I need to "pause" and catch my breath!
Cheers,
Kimbob
|
Hi Gareth,
Gotcha!
"This is sometimes called the 'parenthesis' and in this case is a relative clause as it tells us more about the boy."
(This is sometimes called the 'parenthesis' and, in this case, is a relative clause as it tells us more about the boy.)
Okay, so I've added two commas, right or wrong. But should there be another before "as it tells us more about the boy".
At my age, I need to "pause" and catch my breath!
Cheers,
Kimbob
Comment Written 25-Feb-2021
Comment from Anne Johnston
Thank you for sharing all that information about the comma and when to use it. It is sometimes hard to know when to use it or not. We learned all those rules in school many years ago, but sometimes we forget.
reply by the author on 25-Feb-2021
|
Thank you for sharing all that information about the comma and when to use it. It is sometimes hard to know when to use it or not. We learned all those rules in school many years ago, but sometimes we forget.
Comment Written 24-Feb-2021
reply by the author on 25-Feb-2021
-
I always think that the best thing to do is get a kid's textbook. All the basics are there. Everything else gets very complicated very fast! lol Many thanks
GMG
-
You are welcome
Comment from Roxanna Andrews
I have a horrible time knowing when to use them. No matter how many times I am told, I can't seem to keep it in my head. I will save you examples as a help. Thank you for sharing the info.
reply by the author on 25-Feb-2021
 |
I have a horrible time knowing when to use them. No matter how many times I am told, I can't seem to keep it in my head. I will save you examples as a help. Thank you for sharing the info.
Comment Written 24-Feb-2021
reply by the author on 25-Feb-2021
-
Many thanks for the great response, Roxanna. I hate them too! lol All the best G
Comment from Pearl Edwards
I'm glad I never had to home school my children, but I think yours are very lucky to have you to teach them. My something new I learnt, the fronted adverbial. We use these things but don't always (me hardly ever) know what they are called, or even if they've got a name. Good luck with the home schooling.
cheers
PS did I get my commas in the right place LOL
reply by the author on 25-Feb-2021
|
I'm glad I never had to home school my children, but I think yours are very lucky to have you to teach them. My something new I learnt, the fronted adverbial. We use these things but don't always (me hardly ever) know what they are called, or even if they've got a name. Good luck with the home schooling.
cheers
PS did I get my commas in the right place LOL
Comment Written 23-Feb-2021
reply by the author on 25-Feb-2021
-
Yeah, that term had me scratching my head but the rule is sound! I think folk like confusing other folk with technical jargon! All the best G
Comment from dmt1967
I have trouble with commas and this has helped me a lot. Now, if you could only give a lesson on semi-colons, where dashes can be used and the symbol: which I can't remember the name of I think I will... I mean your nine-year-old will be more than ready to face the world lol.
reply by the author on 25-Feb-2021
|
I have trouble with commas and this has helped me a lot. Now, if you could only give a lesson on semi-colons, where dashes can be used and the symbol: which I can't remember the name of I think I will... I mean your nine-year-old will be more than ready to face the world lol.
Comment Written 23-Feb-2021
reply by the author on 25-Feb-2021
-
Semi-colons are the most pointless punctuation. There is never a place where they HAVE to be used, something else can always do their job! lol All the best G
Comment from Ima L. Ami
This is fantastic! I struggle with commas, so I found this to be extremely enlightening. Thanks so much for sharing this information with us. You made understanding the use of commas easy.
reply by the author on 25-Feb-2021
|
This is fantastic! I struggle with commas, so I found this to be extremely enlightening. Thanks so much for sharing this information with us. You made understanding the use of commas easy.
Comment Written 22-Feb-2021
reply by the author on 25-Feb-2021
-
Much appreciated. I keep these handy. GMG
Comment from BethShelby
I hate them too. I know all the rules, but I get in a hurrry and put them in the wrong place. Half of my reviews tell me to take them out. The other half put a bunch in that I left out. It is easier to make short sentences and forget about them.
reply by the author on 25-Feb-2021
|
I hate them too. I know all the rules, but I get in a hurrry and put them in the wrong place. Half of my reviews tell me to take them out. The other half put a bunch in that I left out. It is easier to make short sentences and forget about them.
Comment Written 22-Feb-2021
reply by the author on 25-Feb-2021
-
Reviewers! It's the ones that pass themselves off as experts you have to watch for! lol Best thing I did was get a child's textbook. Has all the basics right there. All the best G
