Reviews from

Feeding the Bums

They would sit on the tracks and beg for food

39 total reviews 
Comment from DonandVicki
Exceptional
This work has reached the exceptional level

I think it was the photograph that pulled me into reading your poem, We had a pump like that to get our drinking water and for bath. I like to think this was a true story/poem, an altruistic poem.

 Comment Written 19-Oct-2024


reply by the author on 23-Oct-2024
    Don and Vicki, I am so sorry this is late. And I thank you so very much for this awesome review and comments, and the generous six stars. I just had lunch with my remaining four siblings today, so I read them the poem about what I remembered and they said I was right on. I can't believe I remembered it all these years later. Anyway we had a good laugh at how many times we took them food and would sneak around. What memories.
    Thanks again, my dear friend. Love, Debi
Comment from TPAC
Excellent
Not yet exceptional. When the exceptional rating is reached this is highlighted

An enlighten storyhandled as a professional, by my given opinion. Lovely, a conveyance capturing a past event charms; curious children: active in the world. Your parents were justly looking after your safety. Bums are unpredictable: some mentally unbalance in mind. I thought, you kids did great. You exercised your religious faith: caring fir others. God protected you from anything else intended: that day. Just my viewpoint.

 Comment Written 19-Oct-2024


reply by the author on 23-Oct-2024
    TPAC, I thank you so very much for this awesome review and comments. I just had lunch with my remaining four siblings today, so I read them the poem about what I remembered and they said I was right on. I can't believe I remembered it all these years later. Anyway we had a good laugh at how many times we took them food and would sneak around. What memories.
    Thanks again, my dear friend. Love, Debi
Comment from Sandra Stoner-Mitchell
Excellent
Not yet exceptional. When the exceptional rating is reached this is highlighted

I'm sure they were very grateful for the food you and your siblings gave them. We are not all lucky enough to have a warm home, a bed, and food in our tummies. This is a lovely contest entry, and fun too. But mom was right; it could be dangerous. Good luck with this fabulous poem in the contest. Warm hugs, Sandra xx

 Comment Written 19-Oct-2024


reply by the author on 23-Oct-2024
    Hi Sandra, I thank you so very much for this awesome review and comments. I just had lunch with my remaining four siblings today for my birthday, so I read them the poem about what I remembered and they said I was right on. I can't believe I remembered it all these years later. Anyway we had a good laugh at how many times we took them food and would sneak around. What memories.
    Thanks again, my dear friend. Love, Debi
Comment from ~Dovey
Excellent
Not yet exceptional. When the exceptional rating is reached this is highlighted

Hello, mystery poet!

I love that you chose a poem for this contest. When I read the rules, I was wondering if it would be poetry or prose. Your rhymes were delightful, as was the story of that day when you were only five.

You've made us empathize with your older siblings, and how nice, at five, that you escaped the punishment from your parents. I am sure the bums appreciated you all. It beckons us to another age, another time.

I am here at FanStory quite infrequently these days, so I've no clue as to your identity, but I wish you well in the contest. Great job on your poem!

Kim

 Comment Written 19-Oct-2024


reply by the author on 23-Oct-2024
    Hi Kim, I thank you so very much for this awesome review and comments. I just had lunch with my remaining four siblings today, so I read them the poem about what I remembered and they said I was right on. I can't believe I remembered it all these years later. Anyway we had a good laugh at how many times we took them food and would sneak around. What memories.
    Thanks again, my dear friend. Love, Debi
Comment from Begin Again
Excellent
Not yet exceptional. When the exceptional rating is reached this is highlighted

Especially back in the days when work was hard to find and pay was barely anything for those who did work hard, the people left to scrounge on their own didn't have help except from those who opened their hearts like you. Well written poem.
Smiles, Carol

 Comment Written 19-Oct-2024


reply by the author on 23-Oct-2024
    Hi Carol, I thank you so very much for this awesome review and comments. I just had lunch with my remaining four siblings today, so I read them the poem about what I remembered and they said I was right on. I can't believe I remembered it all these years later. Anyway we had a good laugh at how many times we took them food and would sneak around. What memories.
    Thanks again, my dear friend. Love, Debi
Comment from EeanBlack
Excellent
Not yet exceptional. When the exceptional rating is reached this is highlighted

Awesome. Some homeless people can be dangerous. Mental illness, drug addiction, violent ex-cons. Mostly, though, I've noticed that they are very grateful for anything you share. Most people don't share anything at all. This was good to read and it restores a little hope in society. Just a little.

 Comment Written 19-Oct-2024


reply by the author on 23-Oct-2024
    Hi Eean, I thank you so very much for this awesome review and comments. I just had lunch with my remaining four siblings today, so I read them the poem about what I remembered and they said I was right on. I can't believe I remembered it all these years later. Anyway we had a good laugh at how many times we took them food and would sneak around. What memories.
    Thanks again, my dear friend. Love, Debi
reply by EeanBlack on 24-Oct-2024
    I ran into a homeless guy (bum) last Saturday in Oklahoma City. I gave him twenty dollars, but, he wouldn't take it. So, I told him if he let me pet his beautiful little Labrador puppy, I would pay for the petting. I got to pet a puppy. Life is awesome.
reply by the author on 24-Oct-2024
    Believe me that was no bum. The ones we knew I guess weere really dangerous añd hung on the tracks to try to avoid getting caught. I had lunch w my siblings yesterday and they said these men were offered jobs on the railroads but wouldn't take them cause they were mostly felons
Comment from zanya
Excellent
Not yet exceptional. When the exceptional rating is reached this is highlighted

This poem for the One Day at Five contest is so charming telling of another time when life was a lot simpler and what a beautiful pic to illustrate- wish I had 6 - has my vote.

 Comment Written 19-Oct-2024


reply by the author on 23-Oct-2024
    Hi zanya, I thank you so very much for this awesome review and comments. I just had lunch with my remaining four siblings today, so I read them the poem about what I remembered and they said I was right on. I can't believe I remembered it all these years later. Anyway we had a good laugh at how many times we took them food and would sneak around. What memories.
    Thanks again, my dear friend. Love, Debi
Comment from BermyBye50
Excellent
Not yet exceptional. When the exceptional rating is reached this is highlighted

This is an excellent entry in the One Day at Five contest in the form of a rhyming poem. You tell of familiar story of children being warned by their parents not to do something that may prove harmful, but is enticing enough to disobey the warning which eventually leads to being punished.

Note: two minor corrections

And even can(s) of my dad's chew

And what a punishment they (all) got

All the best in the contest,

Eugene

This rating does not count towards story rating or author rank.
The highest and the lowest rating are not included in calculations.

 Comment Written 19-Oct-2024


reply by the author on 19-Oct-2024
    Hi Eugene, I appreciate your very kind comments so very much. You are so thoughtful. I do have a couple questions about your suggestions, since I always appreciate feedback.

    But since my poem is eight syllables and metered, adding all in the line would make it 9 syllables and throw off the meter.

    I could use this, but I found it boring. "And we took a can of dad's chew". But we are talking about a single can of chew, so I guess if ever a poem felt like it didn't have to be perfect grammar it was this one. The chew line is suppose to tie in from the one above it. " We took some water for the stew, and even can of our dad's chew. But it was only one.

    So do you think I should change it back to how we first had it then?

    Thanks again, Eugene. I always appreciate it.
reply by BermyBye50 on 19-Oct-2024
    OK. I had not realized the poem was in meter. In that case do not change it. Its great just as you wrote it.
Comment from Tom Horonzy
Excellent
Not yet exceptional. When the exceptional rating is reached this is highlighted

I haven't heard from you in awhile which leaves me puzzled
I then cHecked my Buddy list
You weren't there
What made me inquisitive are the b.d. Wishes I ve seen 2day is that you they r well wishing?

This rating does not count towards story rating or author rank.
The highest and the lowest rating are not included in calculations.

 Comment Written 19-Oct-2024


reply by the author on 19-Oct-2024
    Hi Tom, I reviewed you a couple weeks ago. I made the effort cause I missed you so I am glad to hear from you now, but this is a blind contest so I have to change my comments so I don't get caught. It was good seeing you, but yes, look in your portfolio and you will see me. And yes, it is my birthday today but I am slightly overwhelmed by such generous and lovely posts.
    Good to see you again, my friend.
reply by the author on 19-Oct-2024
    Hi Tom, I reviewed you a couple weeks ago. I made the effort cause I missed you so I am glad to hear from you now, but this is a blind contest so I have to change my comments so I don't get caught. It was good seeing you, but yes, look in your portfolio and you will see me. And yes, it is my birthday today but I am slightly overwhelmed by such generous and lovely posts.
    Good to see you again, my friend. And I am a fan of yours. I get your posts, but I can't review much. Maybe it is that you aren't of me? I am not sure.
    Thanks again tho.
reply by Tom Horonzy on 19-Oct-2024
    Happy Birthday, friend
    How do people on FS know when a b. d. Is
    ?
reply by the author on 19-Oct-2024
    Hi Tom, you don't know how good it is to hear from you. I know for me when I do the birthday tributes,.I either ask or I look on people's profile..Like for instance my profile tells my birthday, because they asked me when my birthday was.